Percentage of Completion and Job Costing: How Job Cost Data Drives Revenue Recognition?

By Tammy Hoang, QuickBooks ProAdvisor — Construction Bookkeeping Specialist | Construction Cost Accounting
(949) 889-3283 | www.constructioncostaccounting.com

Direct answer: under the percentage of completion method, job costing supplies the numbers. The most common version, the cost-to-cost method, divides the job costs recorded to date by the estimated total cost of the contract. That percentage is applied to the contract price to find the revenue recognized so far. If the job cost records are incomplete or the estimated total cost is out of date, the percentage and the revenue are wrong.
This guide shows how the formula works, why the estimated total cost has to be revised during the job, how to compare revenue earned with amounts billed, and what the job cost records need to contain. The illustrative figures are arithmetic for teaching, not CCA client data. It builds on CCA's percentage of completion guide and job costing guide.
1. The Formula: Job Costs Divided by Estimated Total Cost

CCA's guide states the cost-to-cost calculation as "Percentage Completed = Costs Incurred to Date / Total Estimated Costs." Source: CCA, Percentage of Completion Method. Deltek describes the same two steps: compile all actual, direct costs for the project, then divide by the estimated total contract costs. Source: Deltek. Woodard adds that revenue is recognized in proportion to the share of total estimated costs incurred to date.
Job costing is what produces the top number in the fraction, and careful job cost bookkeeping is what keeps that number complete. Every labor, material, equipment, and subcontractor cost has to be coded to the job for the percentage to mean anything. Woodard says accountants "should have an accurate database of cost information," and that "more than one pair of eyes should repeatedly and systematically verify the information's accuracy." Source: Woodard.
Here is a worked example. A contract is priced at $1,500,000, with an estimated total cost of $1,200,000. After three months, job costing shows $480,000 of costs.
Step | Calculation | Result |
Percent complete | $480,000 ÷ $1,200,000 | 40% |
Revenue recognized to date | 40% × $1,500,000 | $600,000 |
Gross profit recognized to date | $600,000 − $480,000 | $120,000 |
2. Keep the Estimated Total Cost Current

The bottom number in the fraction is an estimate, and it changes. Woodard advises, "Always go back and check numbers. Is the budget still reasonable? Does it need updating?" It also says change orders should go through the same estimating steps, and that if revenue increases while estimated costs stay flat, a change order may be missing from the system. Deltek says change orders "necessitate an adjustment to the completion percentage calculation," and that if a change order raises costs more than it raises contract revenue, gross profit margin for the period can fall.
Continue the example. Material prices rise, and the estimated total cost is revised from $1,200,000 to $1,260,000. By the next period, job costing shows $630,000 of costs.
| Revised estimate ($1,260,000) | Estimate not updated ($1,200,000) |
Percent complete | $630,000 ÷ $1,260,000 = 50.0% | $630,000 ÷ $1,200,000 = 52.5% |
Revenue recognized to date | $750,000 | $787,500 |
Gross profit recognized to date | $120,000 | $157,500 |
Leaving the estimate unchanged overstates revenue and profit by $37,500 ($787,500 − $750,000). The job cost records were identical in both columns. Only the estimated total cost differed, which is why the estimate is reviewed every period and not left at its bid value.
Do your job costs support your percentage of completion?
Construction Cost Accounting helps contractors keep job costs and WIP reporting organized.
constructioncostaccounting.com | (949) 889-3283
3. Compare Revenue Earned With Amounts Billed

Revenue recognized under percentage of completion rarely equals what has been invoiced. Deltek explains that overbilling occurs when a contractor bills for more than the work actually completed, which can create a "billings in excess of costs" liability. Underbilling is the reverse, billing for less than the work completed, which can create a "costs in excess of billings" asset and a cash flow shortfall. Woodard describes the same two accounts: billings in excess of costs as a current liability and costs in excess of billings as a current asset.
In the example, suppose billings to date are $700,000 at the second period. Revenue earned is $750,000, so the job is underbilled by $50,000. At the first period, billings of $660,000 against earned revenue of $600,000 meant the job was overbilled by $60,000. The same job moved from overbilled to underbilled in one period. In construction accounting, a work-in-progress (WIP) schedule shows each job's percent complete and whether it is over or under billed. Woodard recommends preparing it monthly because missing change orders and billing errors are easier to catch.
4. What the Job Cost Records Need to Contain?

In construction accounting, a construction bookkeeper supports the percentage of completion method by keeping these records:
Every labor, material, equipment, and subcontractor cost coded to the job, so the cost-to-cost numerator is complete
An estimated total cost for each job, with a note of the date it was last reviewed
Change orders recorded with both the added contract price and the added estimated cost
Billings recorded by job, so earned revenue can be compared with amounts invoiced
A monthly WIP schedule that shows percent complete and over or under billing for each job
A contractor's CPA decides which revenue recognition method applies for tax and financial reporting. The job cost bookkeeping above supplies the job-level data either method needs.
Where Construction Cost Accounting Fits In?

Construction Cost Accounting provides construction bookkeeping services for contractors whose revenue recognition depends on accurate job costs. Our construction bookkeeping services cover:
Job Costing set up by project, with every cost coded to the job
A WIP Analysis Financial Report built from your job cost records
Accounts Receivable by job, so billings can be compared with revenue earned
QuickBooks Accounting in QuickBooks Online or Desktop, kept current for every job
A construction bookkeeper who keeps your job cost bookkeeping organized
Learn more about our construction bookkeeping service, or visit www.constructioncostaccounting.com
The percentage of completion method is only as accurate as the job costing behind it. The cost-to-cost percentage divides recorded job costs by the estimated total cost, so both numbers must be right. In the example, an estimate left at its bid value overstated revenue by $37,500, and the same job swung from $60,000 overbilled to $50,000 underbilled in one period. Contractors who code every cost to the job, revise the estimate, and review a monthly WIP schedule see where each contract really stands. A construction bookkeeper keeps that construction accounting record clean, and Construction Cost Accounting provides these construction bookkeeping services at www.constructioncostaccounting.com.
Talk with a construction bookkeeper today
Set up job costing and WIP reporting with Construction Cost Accounting.
constructioncostaccounting.com | (949) 889-3283



Comments