Negative Liability on Balance Sheet in Construction Accounting
- Cost Construction Accounting
- Jul 8, 2020
- 7 min read
Updated: Nov 11
Your balance sheet is one of the most scrutinized financial statements in construction. Lenders review it before approving loans. Sureties analyze it before issuing bonds. Project owners examine it before awarding contracts. When negative liability accounts appear on your balance sheet, it raises immediate red flags that can cost you opportunities and credibility.
Understanding why negative liabilities occur and how to fix them isn't just about clean bookkeeping. It's about protecting your company's ability to secure financing, win bids, and maintain strong relationships with partners and vendors.
What Is a Negative Liability?
First, let's establish the basics. Your balance sheet follows the fundamental accounting equation:
Assets = Equity + Liabilities |
Liabilities represent what your company owes to others, money to be paid, goods to be delivered, or services to be rendered. Under normal circumstances, liability accounts carry credit balances (positive numbers), because they represent obligations your company hasn't yet fulfilled.
A negative liability means the account shows a debit balance instead of a credit balance. Essentially, the accounting system is telling you that instead of owing money, the other party owes you money. While this might sound beneficial, it's actually a signal that something has been recorded incorrectly in your books.
Negative liabilities distort your financial position, create confusion during audits, and can trigger concerns from stakeholders who rely on your financial statements to make decisions.
Why Negative Liabilities Are Problematic in Construction
Construction companies face unique scrutiny when it comes to financial reporting:
Bonding Capacity: Sureties calculate your bonding capacity based on your working capital and net worth. Negative liabilities artificially inflate these numbers, which means your actual financial position is weaker than it appears. When discovered during underwriting, this can result in bond denial or reduction.
Loan Covenants: Many construction loans require you to maintain specific financial ratios. If negative liabilities are masking the true state of your accounts payable or other obligations, you might unknowingly be in violation of loan covenants.
Bid Qualification: Project owners conducting prequalification reviews want to see clean, accurate financials. Negative liability accounts suggest poor internal controls and raise questions about whether your company can manage project finances effectively.
Cash Flow Management: When your books don't accurately reflect what you owe, you can't effectively manage cash flow. This is particularly dangerous in construction, where timing between receivables and payables can make or break your operations.
Common Causes of Negative Liabilities
1. Overpayments to Vendors (Negative Accounts Payable)
Accounts Payable should always show what you owe to vendors and subcontractors. Every bill you enter creates a credit (increases the liability), and every payment creates a debit (decreases the liability). When these don't match, problems arise.
Example Scenario:
On May 1st, your accounting team enters a bill from a concrete supplier for $10,000. This increases Accounts Payable by $10,000.
On May 15th, someone processes payment but accidentally enters $10,600 instead of $10,000. The extra $600 overpayment creates a negative balance in Accounts Payable for that vendor.
This commonly happens when:
The payment processor doesn't reference the original bill amount
Multiple bills exist and payments are misapplied
Credits or discounts aren't properly recorded before payment
Rush payments are made without verifying the amount due
Construction-Specific Issue: In construction, you often receive multiple bills from the same subcontractor throughout a project. If someone pays "the last three invoices" without checking the exact outstanding balance, overpayments are easy to make especially when change orders, back charges, or retention complicate the math.
2. Loan Accounts Without Opening Balances
When you finance equipment or vehicles, the loan should be set up with an opening balance that reflects what you owe. Each payment reduces this balance until it reaches zero.
Example Scenario:
Your company purchases a $45,000 excavator with a $35,000 loan and a $10,000 down payment. The correct entry should:
Increase Equipment Asset by $45,000
Increase Equipment Loan Liability by $35,000
Decrease Cash by $10,000
If the bookkeeper forgets to enter the $35,000 opening balance for the loan, then records monthly payments of $800, the loan account becomes increasingly negative. After 12 months of payments, instead of showing a balance of $25,400 owed, it shows negative $9,600.
Why This Happens:
The loan was set up in a rush
The person entering the loan didn't understand the correct journal entry
Equipment was purchased before the loan was finalized, and the opening balance was never added later
Multiple people handled different parts of the transaction
Construction Equipment Context: This is particularly common with construction equipment because companies often trade in old equipment, receive manufacturer rebates, and structure complex financing deals. Each component needs to be properly recorded, or the loan account will be incorrect from day one.
3. Unapplied Credits and Vendor Rebates
Construction companies often receive credits from suppliers for returned materials, early payment discounts, or volume rebates. If these credits aren't properly applied to open bills, they can create negative balances.
Example Scenario:
You return $3,000 worth of damaged lumber to your supplier. They issue a credit memo, which your bookkeeper enters into the system. However, instead of applying this credit to an open bill, it sits in the vendor's account as a standalone credit. When the next bill is paid in full without using the credit, the vendor's account shows a negative $3,000.
4. Duplicate Payments
In the fast-paced world of construction, where project managers, field supervisors, and accounting staff all interact with vendors, duplicate payments happen more often than you'd think.
Someone might pay a subcontractor's invoice from the field, while accounting also processes the same invoice when it arrives by mail. The second payment creates a negative balance because there's no outstanding liability to pay against.
How to Find Negative Liabilities
Most accounting software can generate reports that show negative balances:
In QuickBooks:
Run a Balance Sheet report
Scroll through your liability section
Look for any accounts showing in parentheses or with negative signs
Run an A/P Aging Summary to find negative vendor balances
In Sage 300 CRE or Foundation:
Generate a Balance Sheet as of your current date
Review the Accounts Payable Aging report for credits
Check individual vendor account balances
Warning Signs:
Total Accounts Payable seems unusually low
Individual vendor balances show as negative or in parentheses
Loan accounts decrease to zero before the loan term ends
Your balance sheet doesn't reconcile properly
How to Fix Negative Liabilities
Fixing Negative Accounts Payable
Step 1: Identify the Cause Pull a vendor transaction report to see all bills and payments. Compare what was billed against what was paid.
Step 2: Document the Overpayment Contact the vendor to confirm they received the overpayment and verify whether they've issued a credit or refund.
Step 3: Correct Your Books
If the vendor will refund:
Record the expected refund as an Accounts Receivable
Create a journal entry to move the negative balance out of Accounts Payable
If you'll use the credit on future purchases:
Leave it as a vendor credit
Apply it to the next bill you receive
Do NOT let it remain as negative Accounts Payable
Proper Journal Entry to Correct:
Debit: Other Current Asset (Vendor Credit) - $600 Credit: Accounts Payable - $600 |
This removes the negative liability and accurately reflects that the vendor owes you credit or cash.
Fixing Negative Loan Accounts
Step 1: Determine the Original Loan Amount Gather your loan documents to identify the starting principal balance.
Step 2: Calculate What Should Have Been Recorded Review all payments made to date. Calculate what the current balance should be.
Step 3: Create a Correcting Entry
If the opening balance was never recorded:
Debit: Equipment (or other Asset) - $35,000 Credit: Equipment Loan (Liability) - $35,000 |
Then review each payment to ensure principal and interest were correctly allocated.
Step 4: Reconcile After corrections, the loan balance should match your lender's statement.
Prevention Strategies for Construction Companies
1. Implement Strong Payment Procedures
Always pay from the bill, not from memory or verbal requests
Require approval before processing payments over certain thresholds
Use two-person verification for all vendor payments over $5,000
Review the A/P Aging report weekly to catch irregularities early
2. Set Up Loans Correctly from Day One
Create a checklist for recording new loans and equipment purchases
Ensure the person entering loans understands debits and credits
Have a senior accountant review all loan setups within 48 hours
Reconcile loan accounts monthly against lender statements
3. Train Multiple People
Don't let one person control the entire A/P or loan recording process. Cross-training creates accountability and catches errors before they compound.
4. Monthly Close Procedures
Include a specific step in your monthly close to review:
All liability accounts for negative balances
Vendor accounts with credit balances
Loan balances against statements
The Bottom Line
Negative liabilities aren't just cosmetic issues on your balance sheet. They represent real problems with your accounting processes that can:
Reduce your bonding capacity when you need it most
Trigger loan covenant violations
Disqualify you from bidding on projects
Mask cash flow problems until it's too late
Damage your reputation with sureties and lenders
For construction companies operating on thin margins and managing complex projects, accurate financial reporting isn't optional, it's essential for survival and growth.
If you've discovered negative liabilities on your balance sheet, don't ignore them. Address the root cause, implement proper corrections, and strengthen your processes to prevent recurrence. Your ability to win the next big project may depend on it.
Need help cleaning up your construction company's balance sheet?
Construction Cost Accounting specialists can identify issues, implement corrections, and establish systems to keep your books accurate. Contact us for a free consultation on your financial processes.
Comments